If someone pays to use your facilities, comes back regularly and recommends you to their friends, are they really any less of a member because they don't pay by direct debit?
There's a familiar conversation in the fitness industry… "We've got lots of casual users coming in once a week for a swim, a gym session or a class. We're trying to upgrade them to full membership."
Now there's nothing wrong with that. If someone visits regularly, a membership might save them money, give them more flexibility and provide a more predictable income for the club.
But what if they don't want one?
What if they're perfectly happy paying as they go? What if they prefer the flexibility, don't like direct debits or simply don't visit frequently enough to justify a monthly commitment?
We recently discussed this on our Lead, Convert, Retain livestream with Keith Small and John Preston. And it raised an interesting question for both the gym and padel industries:
Are we spending too much time trying to convert people, and not enough time looking after the customers we've already got?
PAYG (Pay As You Go) doesn't mean less valuable
There are plenty of reasons why someone might choose to pay as they go.
Perhaps they're older and don't like direct debits. Perhaps they travel frequently. Perhaps they only want to swim once a week or use the gym occasionally.
Or perhaps they simply prefer knowing they're paying for what they use.
As John pointed out, some PAYG customers might actually be more commercially valuable than monthly members. They're paying a higher price per visit, without receiving the discount that comes with a membership.
We shouldn't automatically assume that a direct debit customer has a higher lifetime value.
Of course, we need to understand the numbers. How frequently do they visit? How much do they spend over a year? What does it cost to serve them? Would membership genuinely offer better value? Better value for them, or for the club?
But there's a more fundamental point.
If someone is paying to use your facilities, they're already a customer. They're already choosing your business over other options.
Why would we treat them as a sales prospect first and a customer second?
Serve first. Sell second.
Keith made a point during the conversation that I think is particularly important.
If someone never takes out a monthly membership, would they still rave about your club?
Would they talk about how welcome they feel? How the staff remember them? How easy it is to visit? How much they enjoy the experience?
That's the real test… We need to understand why people are coming, what they want and how we can help them.
Rather than immediately offering a discount to join, ask a few questions.
What would you like to achieve? How often do you think you'll visit? What do you enjoy most about coming here?
These questions open up a much wider conversation.
Someone who comes for a weekly swim might be benefit from a health check. Someone who attends a class might enjoy a six-week programme. Someone who visits occasionally might appreciate a guest pass to bring a friend.
It's not about finding something else to sell them. It's about finding something else that might help them.
Yes, sometimes the right recommendation will be a membership. But it should be based on what works for the customer, not simply what works for the sales target.
What gyms can learn from padel
There's an interesting difference between the gym and padel industries.
In gyms and leisure centres, we're often trying to convert casual users into monthly members.
In padel, the vast majority of players are perfectly happy paying for individual court bookings.
There are memberships, of course, but often the main benefit is the ability to book further in advance or receive a small discount.
People might play three times a week and still prefer to pay for each game.
So, what are padel clubs doing to keep those players coming back?
Quite a lot, actually.
The first thing is understanding their playing habits. Depending on the platform, clubs can identify regular players, see how frequently they book and communicate with them in a much more targeted way.
But the really interesting bit is what happens once someone arrives.
Padel is a social sport. People need other people to play with. They want to know there will be a game, that they'll meet people of a similar standard and that there'll be something happening when they turn up.
A good social session, a regular Americano tournament or simply knowing that there's a game available next Thursday can be a powerful reason to return.
And that's something gyms could learn from.
Because people don't always visit a gym purely for exercise either. They come for the people, the routine, the coffee afterwards, the aqua class with their friends or the sense of belonging.
Connection is a powerful reason to keep coming back.
One more visit
One of the themes of our conversation was the value of creating one more visit.
Not necessarily another membership. Not necessarily a big new campaign.
Just one more reason for someone to come back.
For a gym or leisure centre, that might be:
- A health check or body composition appointment.
- An invitation to a new programme or activity.
- A guest pass to bring a friend.
- A personal message if they haven't visited for a couple of weeks.
- An introduction to another service they might enjoy.
For a padel club, it could be:
- An invitation to the next social session.
- A place in an upcoming tournament.
- A beginner session with free racket hire.
- The chance to try a different racket.
- A coffee after the game and a reminder to book the same time next week.
Some of these things cost very little.
We talked about free racket hire, a coffee and even a simple one-page guide to the basic rules of padel. Small things that make someone feel welcome, give them something useful to take away and make it easier to return.
It's not about giving away your product. In fact, John was clear that he wouldn't advocate giving away court time unnecessarily. It's about removing barriers without undermining the value of what you offer.
The same applies in gyms.
A free guest pass isn't just about generating another lead. It's also about helping an existing customer bring a friend, build a social connection and potentially stay longer themselves.
A referral isn't always about making another sale. Sometimes it's about helping the existing customer get more from what they've already bought.
Don't forget the guest journey
Most clubs have a fairly well-developed member journey.
There's an induction, an onboarding process, follow-up communication, reviews and opportunities to introduce people to different services.
But what happens to the guest?
Do we have a journey for someone who pays for a single visit? What about someone who comes to a social session at a padel club for the first time?
We need to think about what happens after that first visit.
Do we ask what they enjoyed? Do we find out what they'd like to achieve? Do we give them a reason to return? Do we introduce them to something else that might be relevant?
And do we have a plan for what happens if they don't come back?
One of the simplest suggestions from our discussion was to send a "we miss you" message to casual visitors too.
If someone who normally visits every week hasn't been in for a fortnight, why wouldn't we get in touch?
It doesn't matter whether they're on a monthly direct debit. The cost of sending a message is tiny, and the value of one more visit can be significant.
Build a community, not just a membership base
The word community gets used a lot in the fitness industry. Sometimes it can feel like a marketing phrase rather than something we're actively creating.
But padel gives us a very visible example of what community can mean.
People organise games with friends. They meet new people through social sessions. They become part of a regular group. They look forward to seeing the same faces.
And that connection gives them another reason to return.
Gyms have this too. Think about the regulars at an aqua class, the swimming group who meet for coffee afterwards, or the choir that operates within a health club (true story… at BigBox in Huddersfield!)
These are communities within communities.
Not everyone needs a membership to be part of them.
And if we're serious about retention, we need to recognise the value of those relationships rather than measuring everything by the number of direct debits.
Treat everyone like a member
This is probably the simplest point, but it's also the one I feel most strongly about.
I tend to think of PAYG customers as members anyway.
They might not be members in the financial or contractual sense, but they're using the facilities, paying for the experience and choosing to come back.
If we're treating them differently because they're not on a direct debit, we're missing a trick.
By all means, explain the benefits of membership. If someone visits frequently, show them how they could save money or access more services. Introduce new programmes and invite them to get involved.
But don't make every interaction an upgrade conversation.
Sometimes the best thing we can do is simply look after someone, make them feel welcome and give them a reason to return.
Because the objective isn't always to convert a PAYG customer into a monthly member.
It's to build a relationship that lasts.
Membership is a payment method. Engagement is the relationship.
And whether you're running a gym, a leisure centre or a padel club, that's what keeps people coming back.
Follow GGFit and Lead, Convert, Retain here on LinkedIn for more Retention strategies, or get in touch to talk about specific actions you could implement at your club to improve member and staff retention, and boost business and health.
No comments:
Post a Comment